Take the 2-minute tour ×
Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who like playing board games, designing board games or modifying the rules of existing board games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

With an extremely large variety of Magic: The Gathering Cards that exist out there from so many sets and a loose definition of utility and value in the game, it's often hard to gauge a card's individual worth/price without checking it out online. Of course, the rarity is generally a good indicator, but there are plenty of expensive common and uncommon cards too.

My question is What is the most efficient way of determining card value without individually loking up each Magic card?

share|improve this question
2  
Note that your link for 'expensive commons and uncommons' is very much online-specific; OTOH, there's a very similar article for offline play (the prices are slightly out of date but still fairly close) at starcitygames.com/php/news/print.php?Article=25391 , sorted by set. –  Steven Stadnicki Oct 22 '13 at 0:08

4 Answers 4

The most time efficient way to sort the wheat from the chaff is hard to gauge, there are a number of different ways that will work for different people.

One option is to take a buylist from your preferred website, which will give you prices for most cards that are valuable. This lets you quickly look through a list of cards (often sorted in alphabetical order and set) all in one place, and check if its on the list.

This wont give you the ACTUAL value of your cards, but generally a buy list price indicates whether a card has much value.

many websites will also let you type in a list of cards and bring up their sale prices of each, which might be quicker depending on how quickly you can go through them.

a further option would potentially be a mobile app, many apps have collection trackers where you can enter your entire collection and then traverse the list in the app to get values for them.

whatever you choose, it will probably be pretty time consuming. Rather than going through your cards and comparing them against the web or a list, it might be better to try and learn as many commons and uncommons worth more than a specific threshold (e.g. $1) as possible, and then go through your collection looking for those specific cards, seperating out any rares and foils to check later. While there are plenty of commons and uncommons that are worth money, there arent so many that you cant have a good idea of what most of them are. having a threshold as low as $1 makes it significantly harder, but starting at $5 cuts out a huge number, and gets you most of the value in your collection quite quickly, before making further passes to pick out the rest, knowing you dont need to look for anything above $5.

share|improve this answer

If you didn't want to go online, you can go to a local gaming store and get them appraised. A good gaming store should be able to list out what each card is worth and what they are willing to buy it for.

share|improve this answer

If you know which sets you have, there is an excellent tool for doing this exact thing at http://mtg.dawnglare.com/?p=viz Simply select the set(s) you own and click submit. You will get a picture of every card in those sets with the most expensive on the left & largest, with descending price towards the right. Then you can simply leave that page up and flip through your collection looking for image matches.

Dawnglare pulls prices from TCGPlayer.com.

share|improve this answer
    
I added a sentence about where Dawnglare gets its prices. I would like to know how often it updates. I would also like to know how and when you found out about it. –  Rainbolt Feb 10 at 21:16
    
I searched for Google for "magic card prices by set sized images". Apparently the site that I was looking for was taken offline by the creator, and this arose in it's place. I don't know where I first saw the other site I was thinking of- probably on a MTG forum. –  VolleyJosh Feb 10 at 23:06

I found the online card manager Deckbox to be quite useful. It allows me to add any card to my inventory with a single click and will display prices, has some nice search and filtering functions and even provides a platform for deck building and trading.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.