Take the 2-minute tour ×
Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who like playing board games, designing board games or modifying the rules of existing board games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've tried playing Arkham Horror with 1, 2 and 4 players. I've found that the game seems extraordinarily difficult with less than 4 characters. Simply put, you don't have enough gos to do everything. Gates keep opening, monsters keep appearing, and it only takes 1 curse, a bad monster, or a couple of delayed turns and it's all over. Adding any expansions simply kicks the difficulty up further.

After several frustrating games, I now don't play with less than 4 characters. In a two player game, each of us takes two characters, and plays the game as if there were 4 players. This seems to give a better balance, but is a lot to remember and keep track of.

Has anyone had success playing Arkham with less than 4 characters? In particular, have you managed a reasonable game with two players and two characters (i.e., one character each)? How did you manage it? Did you have to adjust any of the rules?

share|improve this question
    
Can you rephrase the question to better define what makes an enjoyable game? I play 2 player Arkham horror all the time with my wife, we rarely win but it still meets our criteria for enjoyable. –  anon77 Oct 20 '10 at 1:27
    
@Jeremiah - Basically, an enjoyable game of Arkham for me is one where I feel I can make a reasonable amount of difference, and so have at least a reasonable possibility of winning. I find that 2-character Arkham is a bit like being punched repeatedly in the face, with no real chance to react. Until you lose. Is it just me? ;) –  ire_and_curses Oct 20 '10 at 15:20
    
This barely deserves the "house rules" tag... ಠ_ಠ –  The Chaz 2.0 Oct 24 '12 at 20:21
add comment

2 Answers

up vote 17 down vote accepted

Yes, We've played this way many times and it works quite well for an enjoyable game. I highly recommend it. You don't need to make any adjustment to the rules to do so, just make sure that you keep each character's possessions separate! Also remember that certain game elements are based on the number of characters, not players.

One variation you might try is to play two people with one character each. Just skip every other Mythos phase. Essentially each character gets 2 turns between Mythos phases. If you do this, consider yourselves to be playing a 4 character game for all relevant settings. This will ease your bookkeeping headaches although it will also make the game a bit easier.

To address your statement that you find the game difficult under 4 people, you aren't the only one! Here are the stats from 5200 games taken from the Arkham Horror statistics report. If your winning percentage doesn't quite measure up to the below, keep in mind that folks submitting their games to this collection probably have quite a bit more experience playing Arkham Horror than most.

Investigators   Win %   Close % Seal %  Combat % Games
1               38%     3%      6%      29%      100
2               52%     4%      25%     23%      606
3               60%     7%      30%     23%      767
4               65%     11%     39%     15%      2,941
5               69%     16%     39%     14%      378
6               67%     16%     43%     7%       387
7               68%     16%     39%     14%      44
8               73%     25%     42%     7%       60

As you can see, as the investigator count decreases from 5, the game gets progressively tougher. Also you will probably find more success if you are open to the possibility of a combat victory with 1-3 players

share|improve this answer
    
Sorry, I realise my question was ambiguous. We do indeed play with 2 characters each at the moment. I was wondering whether it is possible to play successfully with 1 character each (which your second paragraph addresses). –  ire_and_curses Oct 19 '10 at 22:17
    
@ire_and_curses Great! I prefer the 4 character myself unless I'm playing with my wife who is less of a gamer than I. However if I'm playing solo, I tend to do 1 character but only take every third Mythos phase. That seems to be the "right" difficulty level for me. –  Pat Ludwig Oct 19 '10 at 22:23
    
Thanks for the stats - that's very interesting. As you say, with less players, there's a much higher chance of having to fight the Ancient One to win. –  ire_and_curses Oct 20 '10 at 15:22
    
Fantastic answer - it saved me from having to ask an entirely different question. (I was gonna ask why my group can never seems to lose in Arkham, but I guess it's pretty obvious that it's because we play with 5+ players.) Thanks! –  scraimer Nov 29 '10 at 7:19
1  
@scraimer - thanks for the kind words. With 5+ players make sure you are spawning 2 monsters with every gate. Also, you can look at the statistics report linked above to see which investigators and Great Old Ones might make for a tougher game for you. If you don't have any of the expansions, I do think the base game can be pretty easy. –  Pat Ludwig Nov 29 '10 at 8:03
add comment

Just a strategy suggestion when playing by the rules (one character each, one Mythos phase each turn): you probably might want to almost completely ignore gates, or just seal one occasionally, when this does not detract from other actions, concentrating instead on getting weapons, skills etc. to confront the endgame Ancient One (of course, this strategy is meaningless when the Ancient One is Azathoth).

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.