Take the 2-minute tour ×
Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who like playing board games, designing board games or modifying the rules of existing board games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've just started playing dominion a little while ago, so I'm pretty new. I get the basic tactics (big money, deck thinning, don't buy copper, etc.) and I do ok when the kingdom cards vary. However, when playing the "basic" game [moat, cellar, village, workshop, woodsmith, militia, etc.] I can't ever seem to win and I don't understand why. No one is playing militias (I've tried them to disrupt others strategies...to no avail)

We play "tournament style" where you can pick your first 2 cards to purchase.

Maybe my initial buys are not so good?

I usually start out with smithy+silver, and then pick up a mine when I get my first $5. From then on I usually do: $2=cellar, $3=silver, $4=silver, maybe one more smithy, $5=market, maybe silver, $6-7=gold, $8=province.

Basically I'm trying to do some variant of "smithy big money" but it isn't working out so well.

Does any one have a consistent strategy for the base game that works?

share|improve this question
    
In my opinion, Base is the weakest of the dominion sets (arguably, either Prosperity or Dark Ages is the strongest). –  Powerlord Nov 20 '12 at 18:22
add comment

4 Answers

up vote 6 down vote accepted
  1. Open with Militia and Silver.

  2. Get a remodel on turn 2 to get rid of your bad cards and maybe throw in a smithy or another militia. Skip the mine, it's not really that great a card in this set as it gets pretty useless towards the endgame, whereas with remodel you can still turn gold into provinces.

  3. If you have 3, buy a silver for the first few turns, then maybe switch to village or nothing once silver ends up being one of the worst cards in your deck. At 4, buy maybe 1 smithy, then go with one of the 3 options. At 5, take a market as it's better than silver 95% of the time. At 6-7 take gold, at 8 take a province unless its really early in the game.

  4. Once you get to the point where you only have <2 reshuffles in your deck, but nothing but victory cards! Even take an estate if you have to. At this point, your will only draw each card in your deck about 2 more times, so that duchy starts looking way better than a gold, since the you'll barely be able to use the gold at all.

Forget that workshop, woodcutter, and mine exist. Take 1 moat only if people are getting lot of militias. Maybe take a cellar if you end up with a lot of copper and estates in your deck despite your use of remodel. Take a cellar only if you want to use a lot of actions and already have plenty of silver. Take village if you have a lot of action cards in your deck and consistently not enough actions to play them.

share|improve this answer
    
Interesting. Once the big money variants started beating the snot out of me I pretty much lost interest in remodel. I've also wondered about the usefulness of workshop (I already know woodcutter is almost always a bad choice). Thanks a bunch, lots of good info! –  javamonkey79 Dec 10 '11 at 23:13
    
@javamonkey79 Woodcutter has very specific uses, i.e. when you really need that +buy and there's no other card providing it. In this set there's no need for it. Workshop shines if you're trying to end things quickly on piles, like in a Gardens strategy. –  shujaa Dec 11 '11 at 5:53
1  
I don't really see 1 remodel having a lot of time to be useful if you have no way to pare your deck down. That is my only quibble though. +1. –  aslum Dec 13 '11 at 7:03
add comment

You are buying way too many actions that don't actually combine well. Try buying a single Smithy, and then buy the first thing you can afford from this list for the rest of the game: Province, Gold, Silver. Literally, that's it. You'll be able to buy your share of the Provinces in 14 turns, on average, which is a solid strategy.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Smithy/ Village is a good combination to have a few of, as it will allow you to draw a lot of cards in your hand. A single workshop very early can help to get the silver flowing, and help to get Smithy/Village cards, but no more. From there, buy Province, Gold, or Silver as you can.

share|improve this answer
1  
This question has been settled definitely by simulators. Single Smithy, no Village is far faster than any other number of Smithies/Villages. The Workshop will only slow you down because either you'll draw it dead from the Smithy regularly or you'll need to buy Villages to play it with the Smithy, which also slows you down from buying Silver. See forum.dominionstrategy.com/…. WanderingWinder is one of the top players in the world and this is an easy scenario to simulate. –  philosophyguy Dec 11 '11 at 23:06
    
Wow, that's really interesting. Hmmmm... –  PearsonArtPhoto Dec 11 '11 at 23:31
    
@philosophyguy though improvement can be got with Workshop/Market to get those Villages... –  shujaa Nov 18 '12 at 23:13
add comment

My favorite Dominion article, Building the "First Game" Engine, looks at this problem. The article works out some very good strategies, comparing them to a baseline of Big Money + Smithy. Best of all, the article showcases the depth that a single set of 10 kingdom cards can have. Their answer is complicated (surprising to some, given the common overestimation of Big Money + 1 or 2 other card strategies). The best strategy they find involves a Workshop to pick up early Villages and a Remodel, a Mine, several Smithies and eventually a Militia, with Markets and Cellars "sprinkled in".

Of course it's not a definitive "best solution", but it's several clear steps ahead of an already very competitive baseline.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.