Tag Info

New answers tagged

1

Yes. The only thing that matters for determining card legality is the name of the card. As far as the Oracle is concerned, 2 different printings of shock are the exact same card for all game and tournament rule purposes. From the tournament rules: 3.3. Authorized Cards Players may use any Authorized Game Cards from Magic: The Gathering expansions, ...


7

Wikipedia claims that this is an acronym from earlier in its development which was later discontinued: WotC was sufficiently convinced and contracted LLS to develop the service, which was then known as Magic Online with Digital Objects (MODO). Initially, the idea of charging for virtual goods, as opposed to a subscription model with unlimited ...


13

No, this does not work. Exchanging control using Chimera's ability sets up a continuous effect; the same as the one created by Hypnotic Siren (or Mind Control, etc). When there are multiple effects that are applied in the same layer, they are all applied in timestamp order. This means that because the Chimera's ability resolved after the Siren's ability, ...


5

I believe you have slightly misunderstood the explanation in the video, and you misunderstand how priority works and the difference between instants and noninstant spells (from the Comprehensive Rules: "A player may cast an instant spell any time he or she has priority. A player may cast a noninstant spell during his or her main phase any time he or she has ...


7

When a card is exiled with Nightveil Specter, you may play it in any way it could normally be played under all the normal restrictions (such as timing, paying costs, etc). In the case of exiling Eidolon of Countless Battles (or any other bestow creature), this means you can pay the bestow cost to cast the spell as an enchantment aura. When a creature card ...


-2

Lands may be tapped at any time for mana, though it's usually pointless to do that when you aren't casting a spell or activating an ability. What actually happens is there is something called your "mana pool". This is what is actually emptied at certain phases. The appropriate ruling is as follows: 305.6. The basic land types are Plains, Island, Swamp, ...


9

You can tap lands for mana at almost any time. Pretty much any time you could do anything else, anyway. Among other things, you can tap land for mana any time you want to play a spell or ability and you need mana to do so. You can only untap a land when you untap your other cards during YOUR untap step (or if a spell or ability instructs you to untap a ...


17

Strategies for mono-black against enchantments Targeted discard The best black cards against enchantments are targeted discard spells. Targeted discard lets you deal with practically any card before it hits the battlefield. Getting the most out of them may require some finesse (here is THE guide on that subject.), but these cards are powerful tools ...


5

Yes, you can use any cards you could in Vintage (except for the banned list). See the rules on mtgcommander.net: Commander is played with vintage legal cards, with some exceptions: cards are legal as of their set's prerelease The following is the official banned list for commander games. These cards (and others like them) should not be played ...


5

Sunweb can't block, because the "as though" only applies to blocking restrictions, nothing else) Deadfall doesn't cause anything to lose forestwalk. Anything that had forestwalk still has it, so it has an ability, and Muraganda Petroglyphs doesn't work on it. The relevant comp rule, I suppose, is: 609.4. Some effects state that a player may do ...


4

I understand what you are saying, but Deadfall simply makes Forestwalk ineffective. It doesn't remove any ability or alter the creature's power. It's still 1/1, and as such, Sunweb can't block it. Trying to find convincing wording is hard, but I have no doubt of this. 609.4. Some effects state that a player may do something "as though" some condition ...


4

The ability is removed from the stack, and you do not get your creature back. See: 603.3 603.3 Once an ability has triggered, its controller puts it on the stack as an object that's not a card the next time a player would receive priority. See rule 116, "Timing and Priority." The ability becomes the topmost object on the stack. It has the text of the ...


4

When you put Athreos's triggered ability on the stack, you choose the target opponent. If there are no valid targets (possibly because your only opponent controls Aegis of the Gods), then the ability is not put on the stack and nothing happens. In regards to how the "unless" is handled: 117.12. Some spells, activated abilities, and triggered ...


6

Yes, you can make these work well together. The ruling on Wild Beastmaster actually answers your question: The value of X is determined when the triggered ability resolves. ... So you can have this sequence of events: Declare attackers including Wild Beastmaster (and maybe other creatures). Wild Beastmaster's ability triggers and goes on the stack. ...


8

Start by accepting that your deck won't be as straight-up competitive as it could be without Mox Opal — it's a staple, and cutting staples, especially for budget reasons, inevitably involves giving away some percentage points here or there. Maybe you can gain some improvements in unusual matchups, though. What does Mox Opal do for you? Consider what ...


1

(Prices below are approximations for singles, not playsets, using TCGPlayer prices as of 4/16/2014) Fellwar Stone relies on your opponent having color-producing lands. ~$0.50 Star Compass relies on you having color-producing lands. ~$0.25 Coldsteel Heart comes into play tapped and produces only one color (chosen as it enters the battlefield). ~$1.50 ...


-4

You can't attack with her the second time because when she pops back into play, she has summoning sickness from becoming a new creature. 400.7. An object that moves from one zone to another becomes a new object with no memory of, or relation to, its previous existence. [...] Being a new object, rules for new objects come into play. Since she's a creature, ...


5

My opponent tried to back out of his play by declaring that he had not yet paid the costs for Devour Flesh. The rules don't allow him to back out in the scenario you described. The following are the steps to casting a spell: (601.2a) Place the card on the stack. (601.2b-d) Make some choices including targets. (601.2e) Determine the total cost to ...


3

It's quite simple: Hexproof and Shroud don't prevent damage; they prevent targeting. Lava Burst cannot target something with Hexproof, something Lava Burst must do far before it tries to deal damage.


10

No, Lava Burst cannot damage a creature with shroud or an opponent's creature with hexproof. An opponent's creature with hexproof or shroud can't be the target of anything you control, period. The "cannot be prevented" text only means that prevention effects do not prevent or change that damage. The relevant rules here are: 615.1. Some continuous ...


0

There's no wayto do so. Rule 606.3 says that it has to be that players turn and that player needs to have priority on the stack. None of this conditions is satisfied. But you can use Worst Fears from Journey into Nyx or Sorin Markov's -8 ability or Mindslayer form Scars of Mirrodin and gain control of your planeswalker. That's the only way I suppose.


3

I have never heard of someone saying "Draw" to mean the same thing as "pass turn" or the like. It is typically used as confirmation that you will be drawing a card. For example, one might say "Draw" after casting a card draw spell, for example "Draw 2" while resolving Divination. This is to protect yourself from receiving a game loss if you are somehow ...


1

[ Just answering the question that hasn't been answered yet. ] Does "Draw." constitute a shortcut for "I would like to pass all priority until the next Draw step"? No. Not unless you and the other players had previously come to an agreement. The following are the officially recognized shortcuts according to the Tournament Rules: Certain ...


12

The rules are not definitively on your side but you definitely should have appealed the ruling. According to the MTG Infraction Procedure Guide section 2.3, the default penalty for drawing an extra card is a game loss. However, it also says: If the player received confirmation from his or her opponent before drawing the card (including confirming the ...


6

When a permanent that's a copy of something else leaves the battlefield, it immediately reverts to its original form as printed on the card. Anything that happened to it while it was on the battlefield has no influence whatsoever on it once it is in the graveyard or anywhere else (unless its effect says so). Artisan of Forms stops being a copy as soon as it ...


1

Not quite. It enters the battlefield under the control of Gild's controller. 110.2a. If an effect instructs a player to put an object onto the battlefield, that object enters the battlefield under that player's control unless the effect states otherwise. That's Gild's controller when it resolved. By default, that's the player who cast Gild. By ...


0

What wording would allow me to do that? Move {some land} to {a zone}[1]. Other than abilities, some keyword actions instruct you to do this, which brings us to your next question. "Destroy target land"? Yes, because destroy is defined as move {permanent} from the battlefield to its owner’s graveyard. You'll never see "target" in a cost, though. ...


6

"Sacrifice" and "Destroy" are 2 separate things, though they both result in sending a permanent to the graveyard. You can only ever sacrifice a permanent that you control: 701.14. Sacrifice 701.14a To sacrifice a permanent, its controller moves it from the battlefield directly to its owner’s graveyard. A player can’t sacrifice something that ...


2

The whipped creature will be exiled at the beginning of the next end step, so it will normally only be able to attack once. There is a way to keep it permanently in play if you Exile the creature, then return it to the battlefield with something like Cloudshift. This way, the replacement effect on leaving the battlefield will not occur (Whip doesn't send ...


2

You can only use one of the abilities each turn, and only once per turn when you could normally cast a sorcery. From rule 606.3: A player may activate a loyalty ability of a permanent he or she controls any time he or she has priority and the stack is empty during a main phase of his or her turn, but only if no player has previously activated a loyalty ...


10

When you have basic questions like this about how cards work, the basic rules are a good place to start. Here's the section about planeswalkers, which directly answers your main questions. Planeswalker Planeswalkers are powerful allies you can call on to fight by your side. You can cast a planeswalker only at the time you could cast a sorcery. ...


4

The creature will remain on the battlefield for the remainder of the turn that it came into play. The last phase of each turn is the ending phase, and the first step of that phase is the end step. When that step starts, the triggered ability "Exile it at the beginning of the next end step" will trigger and you will exile the creature. The next part of the ...


8

Yes, the token comes into play under the control of the player who played Gild. This is specified by rule 110.2a: If an effect instructs a player to put an object onto the battlefield, that object enters the battlefield under that player's control unless the effect states otherwise. Gild's effect instructs you (the player who controls the spell) to put ...


10

Short answer: your creatures lose flying. Since both Oblivion Rings are destroyed at the same time, their triggered abilities "When Oblivion Ring leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to the battlefield under its owner's control." are put on the stack. They are put on the stack in APNAP order: 603.3b If multiple abilities have triggered since ...


10

Yes, you can redirect Guttersnipe's damage to a planeswalker, due to the rule you cited. (That's an actual rule, not a ruling or someone's interpretation.) Guttersnipe is dealing noncombat damage to a player, you are that player's opponent, you control the Guttersnipe, and you may therefore redirect the damage. But saying "planeswalkers are classed as ...


3

A permanent with the Mountain land type. Sacred Foundry can be enchanted with Chained to the Rocks. "Mountain" could mean mean two things: An object whose name is "Mountain". e.g. Mountain An object which has the land (sub)type "Mountain". e.g. Mountain and Sacred Foundry When a card refers to something that can be a name or a type, it always refers ...


3

It can be any card with the land type "Mountain." For example, all of these are valid targets for Chained to the Rocks, as long as you control them: Sacred Foundry, Badlands, Snow-Covered Mountain, Madblind Mountain, any land card affected by Prismatic Omen. In Magic, cards that key off of a card's name will specify "name" in the rules text. See Relentless ...


4

Ambush Commander only affects its controller's Forests, but otherwise, yes. Evacuation will return them to their owners' hands. This doesn't come down to a single rules citation, but ultimately Creature Lands still count as creatures due to this rule: 608.2h If an effect refers to certain characteristics, it checks only for the value of the specified ...


4

As far as I know, there is not a "catch-all" resource that can answer any intermediate question that anyone could possibly dream up. However, I think that you are looking for what I would call "intermediate building blocks". Here are some building blocks that are relevant to nearly any deck build, but are not so hard to understand for an intermediate ...


10

It won't work. Dark Depths' "Dark Depths enters the battlefield with ten ice counters on it." ability is not a triggered ability; you can tell because it doesn't use the words "when," "whenever," or "at," which are part of the definition of "triggered ability" in the Comprehensive Rules: 112.3c Triggered abilities have a trigger condition and an effect. ...


9

You can only activate Crypt Rats on the battlefield. You can activate Rot Farm Skeleton from your graveyard because its ability specifies "from your graveyard." As a rule of thumb, you can only activate an ability from the battlefield unless its text would only make sense in another zone. From the comp rules: 112.6. Abilities of an instant or sorcery ...


0

You can't use it from your graveyard. Abilities usually only work when the card is on the battlefield. Cards that do work from the graveyard are exceptions. See following rules: 112.6. Abilities of an instant or sorcery spell usually function only while that object is on the stack. Abilities of all other objects usually function only while that object is on ...


6

Given the situation you described (2 Slaughter Pacts and 15 lands in hand, and a Lightning Storm on the stack), you can definitely win. I assume that you started by targeting your opponent with Lightning Storm. Then you still have priority, so you cast Slaughter Pact targeting the Spellskite. You also discard 7 lands to Lightning Storm's ability (failing to ...


6

Attacking with Master of Cruelties and other creatures is an illegal action, so they should just undo it and declare attackers again. Specifically, from rule 508.1c: The active player checks each creature he or she controls to see whether it's affected by any restrictions (effects that say a creature can't attack, or that it can't attack unless some ...


4

It enters with 2 -1/-1 counters. Wickerbough Elder enters the battlefield with a -1/-1 counter on it. is equivalent to As Wickerbough Elder enters the battlefield, place a -1/-1 counter on it. Similarly, Persist is also an ability that redefines entering the battlefield (ETB) to add the placement of a counter on the card. Both are replacement ...


4

Soul Link's ability is a triggered ability. From the comprehensive rules: 510.2. Second, all combat damage that’s been assigned is dealt simultaneously. ... 510.3. Third, any abilities that triggered on damage being assigned or dealt go on the stack. State-based checks occur before the triggered ability is resolved, so Player A loses before ...


2

Wickerbough Elder will re-enter the battlefield with two -1/-1 counters in this situation. When it dies, it has two relevant abilities, it's own and the persist ability granted by Cauldron of Souls. Each of those abilities creates a replacement effect that causes it to enter the battlefield with a -1/-1 counter. Those abilities stack, so it enters with two ...


5

The format you're playing is very important to answer this question. Playing Standard, for example, limits your options to the most recent few sets, while on the opposite end of the spectrum, playing Vintage or Commander opens up nearly every card ever printed. Against removal, you can go for creatures with hexproof/shroud (Thrun, the Last Troll/Scythe ...


0

Against removal, try Hexproof (Ranger's Guile, Sheltering Word) or Indestructible (Mortal's Resolve, Withstand Death).


-2

They way it should be handled is having a strategy that either ignore non creature permanent or that is fast enough to not care.



Top 50 recent answers are included