Reputation
13,020
Next tag badge:
99/100 score
11/20 answers
Badges
1 24 55
Newest
 Nice Answer
Impact
~127k people reached

2d
comment What all does Blood Moon affect?
@Pablo I see, oops
Apr
15
comment Can Road Building Progress Card be played with only 1 road remaining?
@AndyT, This wasn't about building 2 roads and then building a settlement; it was about building 1 road, then a settlement, then the second road.
Apr
15
comment Does preventing damage prevent things like land destruction?
@Rainbolt I assume he didn't know that damage is a specific word in MTG, and was going off the general definition, as in something that's harmful to him.
Apr
15
comment Does preventing damage prevent things like land destruction?
Also note that Personal Protection will do nothing to prevent damage to your creatures.
Apr
10
comment Does damage dealt by Searing Blood's delayed trigger cause Satyr Firedancer to trigger?
Is it even possible for a triggered ability (or an ability in general) to be the source of damage?
Apr
7
comment Do enchantments played by my opponent on creatures I control count towards my devotion?
Is there a reason for the downvote?
Apr
5
comment Can I block with Myth Realized if I attacked with it on my turn?
True, but the issue is that as worded, it sounds like the OP may not understand when it stops being a creature.
Apr
5
comment Can I block with Myth Realized if I attacked with it on my turn?
I thought you were asking if it would still be a creature, because you didn't mention using the ability again to make it a creature again. So your question isn't written clearly.
Apr
5
comment Can I block with Myth Realized if I attacked with it on my turn?
Not only will it be tapped, it will not be a creature anymore. It stops being a creature at the end of the turn; the question didn't say anything about turning it into a creature again.
Apr
3
comment Do you still pay 10x the dice when getting the chance card that takes you to the nearest utility if the property is mortgaged?
@Kevin Upon reading / thinking more clearly, I see where the confusion comes from. I think it's ambiguous... by a complete literal reading of the card, then you should still have to pay... you aren't paying rent; you are just following the instructions on the card. My answer assumes a more liberal reading that the intent was to have you pay rent; I could be wrong, and there could be no official answer.
Mar
23
comment Settlers Of Catan 5-6 Expansion
It's not clear what you are asking... if you want to play with 4 people, you just wouldn't be using any of the things that came with the 5-6 player expansion. Are you aware that the expansion is no good on it's own; you still need the main set as well?
Mar
20
comment Can I use a nonbasic land that taps and gives me either a red or white mana if I only have red mana in my deck?
@Kevin I was actually just thinking the same thing, but I'm not sure how much it would help. I don't think it's very likely that a new user coming to ask a question like this would happen to find that other question first.
Mar
20
comment How do Aether Rift and Library of Leng interact?
Ah, interesting. Makes sense; I wouldn't have thought of that though!
Mar
20
comment How do Aether Rift and Library of Leng interact?
"Aether Rift's ability doesn't apply since a creature card was never discarded." This isn't correct. It specifically says that the card is still discarded. Which means that players will still have an opportunity to pay 5 life. But if they don't pay the life, then the card will fail to return to the battlefield because it is not in the graveyard.
Mar
18
comment What is the name of the game where you bid for a hand in descreasing numbers?
Note that this is also called "Up and Down the River."
Mar
15
comment Does Battlefield Forge add two mana to your pool each time it is tapped?
I believe your second question is answered by the other question you asked; mana is there until it is spent or until the end of the step/phase. The tapped status of the land has nothing to do with it.
Mar
13
comment When a permanent is being made to copy another, does it count as entering the battlefield?
Upvoted because redundant or not; answers with rules quotes are better.
Mar
13
comment When a permanent is being made to copy another, does it count as entering the battlefield?
That is a fair point; I'm just trying to put myself in the place of someone who doesn't understand all the details of the rules. I actually think that 603.6a the rule that makes 706.4 redundant... 603.6a is needed to explain that what matters is the permanent entering the battlefield; NOT "Hamletback Goliath" entering the battlefield.
Mar
13
comment When a permanent is being made to copy another, does it count as entering the battlefield?
I think the rule is needed. Or at least, you need the rule explaining when "enters the battlefield" triggers trigger. Because the confusion comes from the fact that even though "the object" was on the battlefield before, "Hamletback Goliath" was not. So without rules saying otherwise, it's just as logical to say "Hamletback Goliath was not on the battlefield before, but now it is."
Mar
10
comment Do card abilities that grant mana stack?
In the game rules, it is the same as having 2 separate tap abilities. But the question is about cards that grant abilities, NOT about cards that have abilities. The other question doesn't at all address the idea of being granted the same ability multiple times. It is not clear at all that the OP already knows that being granted the same ability multiple times will result in the same thing as simply having 2 separate tap abilities.