17,134 reputation
22761
bio website
location
age
visits member for 2 years, 5 months
seen 3 hours ago

Jun
13
comment Does a +1/+1 counter remove a -1/-1 counter?
@user7268, 1 is the smallest of the numbers 1 and 1. ("Both" and "none" aren't even numbers.)
Jun
13
comment When do transformed creatures go back to their original forms?
Your answer covers when they transform, but the OP asked when they changed face. There's is one case of the latter that transforming doesn't cover. They change to their default face when they change zone (become a new object). You hint at this at the end, but I thought I'd mention it explicitly.
Jun
12
revised Celestial Flare Question declaring blockers
added 591 characters in body
Jun
12
revised Celestial Flare Question declaring blockers
added 591 characters in body
Jun
12
answered Celestial Flare Question declaring blockers
Jun
12
comment Do gods keep their +1/+1 counters if they stop being creatures?
Better yet, Llanowar Reborn prove that +1/+1 counters can exist on non-creatures without relying on rulings.
Jun
11
comment Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
@GendoIkari, It wasn't suppose to be convincing. That was the point. It was as baseless as Rusher's. Nothing linked by the above says anything about mtgcommander.net being official or a source of rules for Commander either. It doesn't do anything more than acknowledge the existence of it. Just like SO acknowledges the existence of PerlMonks. That's not an endorsement. It's definitely not a hand off of control. That's all I was saying.
Jun
11
awarded  Talkative
Jun
11
comment Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
You didn't mention any level 5 judge saying mtgcommander is official. There's no nod from the MTGO to the ban list. In fact, the MTGO ban list implies the MTGO list can be different than the EDH one. "Is based on" is very very different than "is a reflection of". The rule book doesn't mention anything about ban lists of any format. Why would they vote for your answer if they could vote for an answer that had these things you claim??? Unfortunately, they don't exist. If your answer was strong, you shouldn't have to lie about what's in it!
Jun
10
comment Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
No, I just didn't mention that it's wrong. And your update is making things worse. 1st para: Magiccards.info does not get its ban list from Gatherer, as you can see by looking at the very card being discussed. 2nd para: Doesn't seem to be saying anything. 3rd para: Actually, as obvious as you think it might be, it's wrong. WotC defers to mtgcommander.net for Commander.
Jun
10
revised Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
deleted 24 characters in body
Jun
10
comment Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
He's obviously not asking about the rules used by his playgroup but the official ones.
Jun
10
revised Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
added 42 characters in body
Jun
10
comment Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
@Jefromi, Of course it is suppose to be in sync. I have already reported the discrepancy.
Jun
10
revised Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
deleted 81 characters in body
Jun
10
revised Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
added 189 characters in body
Jun
10
answered Which is authoritative: Ban List or Gatherer?
Jun
7
awarded  Enlightened
Jun
7
awarded  Nice Answer
Jun
6
answered Drawing and going first