16,670 reputation
22659
bio website
location
age
visits member for 2 years, 4 months
seen 1 hour ago

Sep
5
comment Why did Experiment One not get a counter when my Undying creature returned to play?
I agree with Fabian. At no time is the SG on the battlefield without the +1/+1 counter, and ETB abilities trigger based on the state of the game after the event (the default), so it's a 3/2 when determining whether the ability should trigger or not. Intermediary "if" conditions are rechecked on resolution, so unless the counter was removed in response to it entering the battlefield, it's still a 3/2 when the condition is rechecked on resolution. Let me know if you want the rule numbers.
Sep
5
comment Why did Experiment One not get a counter when my Undying creature returned to play?
@NAte Kerkhofs, If it wasn't on the battlefield one moment and it is the next, it entered the battlefield.
Sep
4
awarded  Quorum
Sep
4
revised How do I identify non-English Magic cards?
added 142 characters in body
Sep
4
revised How do I identify non-English Magic cards?
added 165 characters in body
Sep
4
comment What are these games?
@murgatroid99, You should be able to see the scaled-down version. If not, let's just say it confirms My Turn Yet's answer.
Sep
4
asked How do I identify non-English Magic cards?
Sep
4
answered How do I identify non-English Magic cards?
Sep
3
comment What are these games?
You can see the side of the box of the base game here (Warning: large image)
Sep
3
comment If a single effect would destroy a permanent multiple times, can regeneration replace it?
Hao Ye, I have changed the answer to which you linked based as a result of my answer in the thread Rainbolt linked. I was actually thinking of that very thread when I made my comment in the answer you linked, but I remembered the conclusion incorrectly.
Sep
3
comment What happens to a creature enchanted with totem armor if both are destroyed at the same time?
@Rainbolt, Oh the irony. I made the comment based on my incorrect memory of this thread, the very thread you posted to prove me wrong. In case you didn't notice, I'm the one who found and posted the relevant rule at the bottom of the thread. Fixed.
Sep
3
revised What happens to a creature enchanted with totem armor if both are destroyed at the same time?
added 162 characters in body
Sep
2
comment What happens to a creature enchanted with totem armor if both are destroyed at the same time?
@Cameron, Like you said, there are two destroy effects. They both happen even though they happen at the same time.
Sep
2
revised What happens to a creature enchanted with totem armor if both are destroyed at the same time?
deleted 27 characters in body
Sep
2
answered What happens to a creature enchanted with totem armor if both are destroyed at the same time?
Sep
2
comment Do +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters remain on a god if it's not a creature
Changing an object's characteristic (power, type, etc) does not cause counters to be removed from it.
Aug
28
revised Does Grindclock's counter reset when it's activated?
added 7 characters in body
Aug
27
comment Does Grindclock's counter reset when it's activated?
By the way, you mentioned a downvoter earlier... When I vote, I vote on the post's merits. It wasn't me; the small error is not enough to merit a downvote.
Aug
27
revised Does Grindclock's counter reset when it's activated?
added 8 characters in body
Aug
27
revised Does Grindclock's counter reset when it's activated?
[Edit removed during grace period]