Partner opens 1D -- I respond 1H -- Partner responds with 2D -- (I have 3 spades, 5 hearts, 1 clubs, 4 diamonds, 13 hcp) --> I'm tempted to bid 3NT now. Should I always get to game with me and partner both having opening strength even if we don't have 8-card fit? In essence, what do I bid here?
- Bidding 2H shows 5 hearts, but not game values.
- Bidding 3NT - we and partner might not have both together NT distribution.
-
1Do you mean that you have 1 diamond and 4 clubs? If you have 4 diamonds and partner has bid them twice, you certainly have an 8-card fit.– rudsJun 19, 2013 at 18:23
-
This hand has great potential, depending on the exact cards held. What is your full hand?– Forget I was ever hereJun 19, 2013 at 22:26
3 Answers
A good general principle is that when you have an opening hand and partner opens, you should get to a game.
Partner has advertised a 6+-card diamond suit (some people may rebid 2D with 2353 shape on this auction, but I prefer 2H) and has limited their values (with a good 17-count or better, partner would have a different bid). So you can see that you (probably) don't have an 8-card fit. You don't describe your hand completely, but if you have half a spade stopper or better, 3NT seems like the right place to play. If partner rebids 4D, this is game forcing and suggests some slam interest; it cannot be passed.
If your spades are bad, probably your best rebid is your 4-card club suit; if partner has a spade holding they can rebid 3NT. Rebidding your hearts is not very attractive because you only have 5 of them.
-
The partnership appears to have a 10-card diamond fit and 26-28 points; enough for 5D, surely? Jun 19, 2013 at 20:13
-
Note that it was stated that clubs were stiff in responder's hand, not a 4 card suit.– user3264Jun 19, 2013 at 21:43
-
It was also stated that the pair didn't (or probably didn't) have an 8-card fit and the suits were given out of the standard order, so my assumption was that the asker mislabeled the suits in the hand given.– rudsJun 20, 2013 at 0:42
The appropriate decision, ranging from (just possibly a) pass to investigating slam is critically dependent on the high cards in your hand. For instance, with these hands:
Axx xx
AQxxx Kx
Kxxx AQxxxx
x Axx
a grand slam is likely. Alternatively, with these two:
KJx xx
AJxxx Kx
KJxx AQxxxx
x Axx
3NT looks like the best contract, and if your 13 points includes distribution then this pair:
KJx xx
QJxxx Kx
KJxx AQxxxx
x Axx
should be in 5D.
In all three examples partner has the same hand, better than minimum for his bid. I can easily seeing many partners bidding the same way without the QD, in which case all actions have to be a bit more restrained. Give us your complete hand, and you will get better advice.
-
On hand number 2 as you show it, I'd not feel at all bad to get to 6D, NOT 3NT. That contract is pretty much a 50% slam even if they lead spades, so not at all bad, at least at matchpoint scoring. And if they do not lead spades, the contract is a very good one.– user3264Jun 19, 2013 at 22:05
-
@woodchips: I'm leading spades on that auction, in a nice even tempo holding either AS or QS, and sitting as demurely as I can while studying dummy. However you are right, 6D is probably good at matchponts, or vulnerable at IMPS. Replace SJx with ST9 and it is a closer call. Jun 19, 2013 at 22:11
-
@woodchips: Of course in all three cases partner might not have the DQ or equivalent, or CAxx might instead be CAJx Jun 19, 2013 at 22:15
I'd head for game in diamonds. You have 13 high card points, but your singleton club is worth 2-3 more provided that you play in a sut contract.
Your partner probably has at least 13 high card points and 5-6 diamonds. You should have 26 high card points or more between you, plus 9-10 diamonds and the club singleton. Unless your opponents have A of clubs, plus A-K of another suit where you and partner both have at least a doubleton, you'll make five diamonds.
The main question is whether you have a good enough fit for slam. That would occur if your opponents had A, K, Q, J of clubs, and scattered values elseshere, say J, J, Q of the three other suits. On the other hand, slam is "off" if partner (or you) have wasted honors in clubs, meaning that your opponents may have useful honors elsewhere.