3

In the rulebook of Civilization (p.26) it says, that

The player declares which of their cities the scout is "sending" the square to during the Start of Turn Phase, and all the icons in that square (including trade, production, culture, coins and resources) are then considered to in that city's outskirts for the rest of the turn.

In many cases in our play groups we forget to declare the cities at each 'Start of Turn Phase'. Then, we declare the cities at the 'City management Phase'. This is sometimes even an agreed rule, because it makes the 'Start of Turn Phase' a much faster. That is because then you will not have to plan the whole round beforehand at the 'Start of Turn Phase'.

Is there any reason that the decision for the "home city" of the scout should be decided at the 'Start of Turn Phase' and not at the 'City Management Phase'? Would it harm the game somehow, if the decisions are made at the 'City Management Phase'?

1

If could affect the game in the way, that you do not know if some player will trade with you. If he does not accept a trade you might be interested in, you could lack the ressources to do what you intended to do and have misplaced your pioneer (or vice versa, could have done some better move due to a surprisingly good deal).

However, we always decide where to use the pioneer during city management, since the game rule causes unneeded memory issues that are only relevant in niche cases (the game is already complex enough by itself).

| improve this answer | |
  • Can you clarify your answer? If I have misplaced my scout, it does not matter if I declare the city for the scout in the 'Start of Turn Phase' or in the 'City Management Phase'. – np8 Feb 18 '15 at 14:42
  • 1
    Say you need 8 hammers to build a building. Your city produces 6 by itself, your scout 1. Now you have the choice of trading 3 points from another player which you can exchange for an eight hammer. This results in 2 possible outcomes: You trade, get the eight hammer and use the scout in order to build the building. Noone trades, you build a building for 6 hammers and waste a hammer you could need in another city or should have placed the scout on a resouce that you cannot farm now. – Nephtyz Feb 18 '15 at 17:01
  • Ok, i got your point now. I upvoted your answer, but I will still wait for some while before accepting any answer as the "most helpful answer". – np8 Feb 18 '15 at 17:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.