When Noxious Gearhulk is played can it be countered by Turn Aside?

I've noticed that some cards say "counter target spell or creature" but turn aside only says "counter target spell ..."

| improve this question | | | | |
  • 8
    "Counter target spell or creature" is not a valid wording for any Magic card. If you are thinking of a specific example of the wording you're thinking about, please name the card. – Hackworth Dec 30 '16 at 23:30

No, Turn aside cannot counter Noxious Gearhulk.

There seems to be some confusion here. When a player plays a creature spell such as the Gearhulk, it is indeed a spell while it is on the stack and does fulfill one of the conditions of Turn Aside's possible targets. However, a creature spell (generally, all permanent spells except Auras) never targets anything, and is therefore never a valid target for Turn Aside. A creature spell is simply on the stack, and when it resolves, it puts the creature it represents onto the battlefield.

Only the Gearhulk's enters-the-battlefield ability can target something. It goes on the stack when the Gearhulk has resolved and entered the battlefield. However, an ability is not the same as a spell, Turn Aside can counter only spells, so Turn Aside cannot counter that ability either.

| improve this answer | | | | |

No, you cannot counter a Gearhulk with Turn Aside.

The Gearhulk is not a spell that targets anything. When it's cast, it's just a creature spell on the stack, without any targets and doing nothing special. Its ability isn't doing anything yet.

After Gearhulk resolves and enters the battlefield as a creature (too late to counter it), its "When Noxious Gearhulk enters the battlefield..." ability triggers and goes on the stack. Now there is a triggered ability on the stack that's targeting something. You'd have to cast a card like Stifle which counters that ability.

| improve this answer | | | | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.