From a collector's point of view, what is the most valuable wargame published by Avalon Hill?

I'm not interested so much in prices as in knowing if there's a "Holy Grail" in Avalon Hill's wargames catalog before the Hasbro purchase.

I looked in eBay listings and BoardGameGeek, but not being all wargames available for sale, it's hard to get the whole picture.

  • 3
    This is surprisingly the first question we've had about pricing for board games. I'm unsure if it should be on-topic, so I've opened a meta discussion about it. – Thunderforge Feb 14 '17 at 20:22
  • I asked about pricing to narrow the question by giving an objective guideline to answer. I'm mostly interested in the "Holy Grail" part, but that's kind of subjective. – Rodia Feb 14 '17 at 20:31
  • 1
    Well "the most valuable, economically speaking" is asking for economic value -- which means price, hence the pricing tag. You're also discussing eBay Listings, and BoardGameGeek information on what's for sale. I'm not sure what else a "most valuable" "Holy Grail" could be referring to. – doppelgreener Feb 15 '17 at 18:56
  • 1
    @Rodia Added. :D – doppelgreener Feb 15 '17 at 20:14
  • 1
    A quick ebay search suggests Longest Day might be the answer... – aslum Feb 16 '17 at 18:36

Prices vary somewhat naturally, especially if you find a motivated seller, or desparate buyer! In general, prices are pretty stable and slowly creep up over time. A reprint can drop prices quickly, but most of the below have difficult rights situations and are unlikely to see full reprints (AoR had a foreign release a while ago).

Games are valuable if they are still played, or weren't printed in enough quantity, preferably both....

Currently, my top 5:

  1. $500 - Star Wars: The Queen's Gambit
  2. $300 - Advanced Civilization
  3. $250 - Axis & Allis Anniversary Edition
  4. $200 - Dune
  5. $150 - Age of Renaissance
  • 3
    The highest voted answer on the meta question about pricing questions indicates that they are on topic, but the community should downvote the answer if it doesn't include information about how they arrived at that price. Could you please add that to your answer? – Thunderforge Feb 21 '17 at 23:56

Of course, it all depends upon definitions... This article claims that to go "all in" on Advanced Squad Leader, you need to drop $3200. But, presumably you meant "a single box"?

If you use EBay as a way to track prices, as of today, there's a $1K price on Advanced Civilization, and the second highest at $600 is ... Queen's Gambit. Those are asking prices, not sale prices.

BoardGame Geek's list of most expensive games available for purchase today, none of them are AH, but based on the lack of hits on EBay, one can assume it's not a particularly liquid market.

Finally, my original answer to this question, quoted this article to give answer of: "Star Wars: The Queen's Gambit"

Star Wars: The Queen’s Gambit: Play as either the trade federation or the Naboo as you reenact the four-fold climax of Star Wars: The Phantom Menace.

Why it’s rare: It’s great, highly complex, and happens to come with 155 individual pieces, a 3D Theed palace, 16 dice, and 180 cards. Sure it was released in the comparatively recent year 2000, but prying one of these suckers from the hands of another Star Wars fan will still cost you.

Price: $300-$1000

  • You caught me on this one, I should have made clear that I meant Avalon Hill wargames before the company was purchased by Hasbro. Should I edit the question? – Rodia Feb 15 '17 at 20:57
  • 4
    @Rodia If that's what you're interested in, then yes, I think you should add that. All that said, I'm a bit surprised none of the older Avalon Hill games made that list.... I love those old games, and they are hard to find, and always seem to be very expensive... – John Feb 16 '17 at 16:22

Starting in I guess the mid-1980's, I played a ton of board war games and had a decent collection. I can remember Avalon Hill catalogs from that time, and often the catalogs were printed some years before I eventually purchased the game.

I was always curious what the most expensive thing was in the catalog. The highest price that I recall for a new-in-box game was $85 for The Longest Day, in a catalog dated, I believe, 1985.

I purchased a copy in the early 1990's, and I eventually sold it in 2015 for around $200 (open, excellent condition, unpunched).

  • While interesting data I am not sure how the price of a game you sold 4 years ago helps determine the most valuable one today. – Joe W May 21 '19 at 2:22
  • Perhaps it was colloquial, but the question specifically referred to the AH catalog. – TheCoolah May 22 '19 at 18:46
  • That is true but a single game does not give much insight into an entire catalog of games, especially with other example games listed as more valuable. – Joe W May 22 '19 at 18:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.