4

Sometimes you will need resources to build your stage of the wonder played. Is commerce allowed particularly in this phase. For example:

The game has begun and we are on the first recruitment phase. Here you are allowed to recruit, build a stage or discard. What if I choose to build a stage or my wonder but I don't have the resources. Am I allowed to trade?

|improve this question
1

Tl;dr: Yes.

A strict reading of the rules would imply that commerce isn't allowed for wonder construction even in the base game:

Throughout all 3 ages in a game, the players will get to build structures (cards) and Wonders (board).

...

Commerce

Often, a player will want to build a structure requiring resources he or she does not produce. If these resources are produced by a neighboring city...

However, the game designer has explicitly stated that you are allowed to use commerce for wonder stages. Given that clarification, it is reasonable to assume that when the Leaders rules are once again ambiguous on the matter, you can again use commerce for wonder stages there too.

|improve this answer
  • Lol, so all this time we have been playing the game wrong. Can someone else confirm that? – Ivelin Rusev Sep 1 '17 at 20:11
  • I was quite surprised to find those rules myself - I thought the answer to your question would be a simple "of course you can", and I stand by that "always allowed" option even though I can't find it in the rules. As tangential evidence I'll point out that many of the wonders' A sides require two of the same grey resource to build. If commerce was not allowed for wonder construction, then if you wanted to complete your wonder you'd be forced to get that duplicate resource yourself, which would be pretty bad since nothing else in the game requires it. – Benjamin Cosman Sep 1 '17 at 20:16
  • I got so confused right now... Can we use trade to build stages of the wonder yes or no... And can we trade in the recruitment phase... Here they are saying its allowed: boardgamegeek.com/thread/832458/…. But there is nothing for recruitment phase of the leaders.. – Ivelin Rusev Sep 1 '17 at 20:24
  • To summarize: I think the answer is yes and yes, in spite of rules which would seem to say no and no. – Benjamin Cosman Sep 1 '17 at 20:27
  • I've updated the answer in light of the BGG thread you found. – Benjamin Cosman Sep 1 '17 at 20:33
1

I agree with Benjamin Cosman’s answer, it is allowed.

I think it can be deduced from the Leaders rules, which say about the Recruitment Phase:

b. Build a stage of a Wonder

To build a stage of a Wonder, the player uses the Leader card selected as a construction marker (face down). To do that, the cost indicated on the Wonder board must be paid, and not the one on the Leader card.

Note: this action will rarely be possible during the first Recruitment Phase, as the cities will ­generally not yet have the resources required for the construction of the first stage of their Wonder.

The note says that it will "rarely" be possible in the first phase, so it must be possible somehow.

If there is no Wonder that allows building the first stage only with the Wonder’s starting resource, then this means it can only be achieved with commerce.

I checked all Wonders that were released up to and with the release of the Leaders extension:

  • Each base game Wonder has 1 starting resource, and each of the Wonder’s first stages cost at least 2 resources to build.
  • The Manneken Pis Wonder has no starting resource, and none of its first stages can be built for free.
  • The Wonder from Leaders has no starting resource, and its first stages cost at least 2 resources to build.

So there doesn’t seem to be a Wonder which would make this possible without commerce. Hence commerce has to be allowed, otherwise it would never be possible.

|improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.