1

Am I missing something? It has come up that my partner and I only have one card left in our hand and we haven't make a Canasta so we can't go out. So we end up picking up and discarding in an endless loop. Is there any recourse other than hoping either me and my partner will pick up a 6th or 7th card to make a Canasta and go out? In the meantime our opponents are racking up points left and right.

  • While the linked question is not about team play; nothing changes there; except that it's much rarer in team play as it requires both partners to make the same fatal mistake. – GendoIkari Feb 3 '18 at 16:41
  • @GendoIkari That question is not a duplicate since it is talking specially about freezing the discard pile and this question is talking about 1 team only have a single card while the other team has multiple cards. In this situation everyone can still draw from the discard pile since it is not frozen just that it is easier to prevent someone from drawing when they only have one card in hand. – Joe W Feb 3 '18 at 16:45
  • @JoeW If the discard pile isn't frozen, it is indeed a different situation... but it's also not nearly as much of a problem; so I guess I assumed that the discard pile was frozen in this case. – GendoIkari Feb 3 '18 at 16:59
  • 1
    @GendoIkari there is no mention of the discard pile being frozen so assuming it is would be a bad assumption. – Joe W Feb 3 '18 at 17:02
1

Assuming that the discard pile is not frozen; then you can continue to score points if your opponents ever discard something that you can play. This will also limit what your opponents can do to score points; they wouldn't be able to just run through the whole deck and score. However, you are still in a bad position; both you and your partner made a major mistake by going down to only one card in hand wihtout having a Canasta yet.

If your opponents are smart, they will take advantage of thisby keeping the discard pile continually frozen; and then they can discard any card safely no matter what; and they will be able to pick up the entire discard pile by using cards in their hand when you discard something they have (which you'll be forced to do every few plays). This way, your opponents can literally score every card in the deck that you haven't already scored. This could even end the entire game in one hand.

There's no rules thing you are missing here; you simply made an error; and it was worsened by the fact that your opponent made the same error. Even though having more cards in hand when your opponents go out is a bad thing; in general having more cards in hand is a good thing. The more cards you have in hand, the more likely it is that you will be able to pick up the discard pile and score more points. If you are worried that your opponent is going to go out soon; you can play your higher-scoring cards to get them out of your hand, while still keeping a few lower scoring cards in hand as to not get stuck.

This also depends on how close you are to a Canasta. If you have a six card set already; then you may be able to go down to one card and hope that you draw the seventh card. This is still risky though. If you have nothing larger than a 5 card set; then you have literally made it so that you can never make a Canasta or go out; because you can't ever add 2 cards to it at the same time.

0

Yes, you missed the fact that getting down to one card, or just a low number of cards, is bad and will limit what you can do. Because of this you where not able to score points and your opponents where able to score a lot of points. I would also guess that because of the situation you had to discard a lot of cards that would help them out in scoring many more points while they could avoid discarding ones that would help you.

  • Ok- I get it. However there is a sweet spot where if opponent goes out you don't want to be stuck with cards in your hand . But OK best not to get low. While I have you...hahaha.. We are newbie players. Can you tell me the difference between the rules for picking up discard pile during regular play and when the pile is frozen. In first case you can pick up if the top card can be used to make a meld from your hand OR just adding the top card to a meld on the table? In frozen pile you HAVE to apply to cards in your hand. You can't add that top card to meld on the table only? – Susan S Feb 3 '18 at 16:48
  • @SusanS Please ask a separate question for that one. This already-existing question might help; though it's not an actual duplicate. – GendoIkari Feb 3 '18 at 17:01
  • @SusanS Getting down to 1 card for both players on a team is much worse then getting stuck with cards in your hand. I have played games where the team that doesn't go out get stuck with a bunch of cards in their hands but still scores more points because they have more cards on the table. – Joe W Feb 3 '18 at 17:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.