5

My opponent attacks me with 10 creatures. I block with Guardian of the Gateless . He can block any number of creatures and gets 1+/+1 counter for each creature blocked. Does he gets +10/+10 and blocks all the creatures simultaniously dealing +13+13 to all of them? Killing them in the process. Or he can block 1 creature at a time and gets damaged by each one. So the best way would be to start blocking the creature with less toughness until he dies?

7

First, Guardian of the Gateless doesn't get 10 +1/+1 counters, but rather a temporary boost until end of turn. Assuming Guardian blocks all 10 attacking creatures, he will get a temporary +10/+10, making him a 13/13 until end of turn.

Now then, during the declare blockers step, you'll order the attacking creatures into a block order and your opponent will order your blockers into an attacking order. This second part is only relevant when there's multiple blockers to an attacker. After this is done, the Guardian's ability will trigger, making him a 13/13.

Now that declaring blockers is done, you will move to the Combat Damage step where you can now assign damage to them. You must assign lethal damage[1] to an individual creature before assigning damage to the next. So for example, you could assign all 13 damage to the first creature and none to the rest, or 4 to first creature and 9 to the rest, any combo really as long as it totals your power of 13 and follows the above guideline.

Depending on what your goals are, you have a few options. From what I'm understanding Guardian will die anyway if the creatures attacking have a combined power of at least 13. Therefore you should assign lethal damage to the creatures you want to get rid of the most. Or if your opponent is attacking with a bunch of small creatures, it might make sense to instead destroy a bunch of little creatures. You need to look at the quality vs. quantity of attacking creatures and what needs to be eliminated for you to survive or win.

Finally, since all 13 attacking creatures have been be blocked, none of them will deal damage to the attacked player or planeswalker (unless they have trample), whether the Guardian deals damage to them or not.


  1. A lethal amount of damage (usually shortened to "lethal damage") refers to an amount of damage that would be sufficient to destroy the creature being damaged, ignoring anything that would prevent the damage or its destruction (e.g. Indestructible). This is usually means an amount of damage equal to the toughness of the creature being damaged, but it could be less (if the creature to which damage is being dealt has previously received damage, or if the creature dealing the damage has deathtouch).
| improve this answer | |
  • 4
    The way you have described damage assignment is potentially misleading. You say that you can assign it in any combination as long as it totals to 13, but that's not really accurate. Once you have chosen the order during the declare blockers step, you have to assign lethal damage to each creature in order before assigning any damage to the next creature. – murgatroid99 Apr 26 '18 at 21:07
  • 3
    @Chris Indestructible actually doesn't factor into it. All you have to do is assign enough damage to equal the creature's toughness to each creature before moving to the next. The game doesn't care that the creature won't die. – Veskah Apr 26 '18 at 22:00
  • 2
    @Chris Oh, I misread. Everything that's blocked will still be blocked even if guardian doesn't have enough damage to mark everyone, he'll just assign 0 to them. He can do that regardless of if he'll survive but if he is indestructible, he'll be a real pain to deal with. – Veskah Apr 26 '18 at 23:13
  • 3
    Heck, once you've declared the Guardian to be blocking creatures then those creatures remain blocked even if a spell or ability removes the Guardian from play entirely. – Arcanist Lupus Apr 27 '18 at 1:53
  • 2
    @chris Important to remember that all combat damage happens at the same time; the assignment order is not an order that they will receive damage in; it’s just an order of distributing your creature’s power. So there couldn’t be anything like “can’t keep blocking after running out of power”. – GendoIkari Apr 27 '18 at 14:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.