9

Does Treasure Nabber grab artifacts tapped with Urza, Lord High Artificer?

  • 3
    Hi Paul; please ask one question per question. How Urza interacts with Treasure Nabber is already a complete question on its own. The exception is when multiple questions are interrelated such that they don't make sense being asked separately — but you can ask about Urza's interactions with other cards separately. – doppelgreener Sep 15 at 16:05
11

It's sort of surprising and counter-intuitive, but Treasure Nabber won't nab artifacts that are tapped for mana with Urza's ability.

The rules are fairly specific about what counts as “tapped for mana”, and it's more specific than we might intuit:

106.12 To “tap [a permanent] for mana” is to activate a mana ability of that permanent that includes the {T} symbol in its activation cost. See rule 605, “Mana Abilities.”

The {T} symbol here is the tap symbol. That is to say, we have to use an ability found on the permanent itself that is similar to the form “{T}: Add some mana.”

This means when we tap an artifact using Urza's ability, even though we get mana out of it and tapped something, it isn't considered to have been “tapped for mana” by the rules: we didn't use an ability found on the permanent we tapped.

The rulings on Treasure Nabber also describe this for us:

An artifact is “tapped for mana” when a player activates a mana ability of an artifact that includes {T} (the tap symbol). Notably, tapping an artifact to pay for a spell with the improvise keyword is not tapping that artifact for mana.

  • 3
    I feel like Springleaf Drum is an interesting alternative example for this question since it uses both the {T} and wording similar to Urza. The activated ability on Springleaf Drum taps the drum for mana but not the creature, so Treasure Nabber steals Springleaf Drum when it is used, but not any Artifact Creature that happens to be playing that drum. – CALEB F Sep 16 at 22:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.