3

Let's say I'm playing Dark Prophecy, which has an ability which states

Whenever a creature you control dies, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.

and I have a Naturalize in my hand.

Suppose I'm attacked, and lose 2 creatures in combat. Because of the combat damage I'll be taking, I can't afford to lose 2 extra life, but I can lose 1, and want the card draw. Can I cast Naturalize after letting it trigger just once, and destroy my own Dark Prophecy before it kills me?

2

No, you cannot.

Creatures die as a state-based action, which means they all die at the same time. This means the triggers from Dark Prophecy go on the stack at the same time. Since these all occur as part of the state-based actions, you can't "interrupt" the placing of the triggers on the stack and either you will get 2 triggers of Dark Prophecy or 0, depending on when you cast Naturalize.

| improve this answer | |
0

No

All combat damage is dealt at the same time, which means that the two creatures will die at the same time, and each one will add a trigger from Dark Prophecy to the stack. At the end of combat damage, the stack will look like this:

[Top of Stack]

Dark Prophecy Trigger

Dark Prophecy Trigger

[Bottom of Stack]

You can decide which order these triggers go on the stack (they're the same so in this case it doesn't really matter), but since they go on at the same time, you don't have a chance to cast Naturalize before they are both on the stack.

You are correct in your thinking that you can cast naturalize after one trigger resolves. However, this doesn't really do what you want: Even though Dark Prophesy is destroyed from Naturalize, any triggers that are still on the stack will still resolve as normal.

As a side note, if the card you draw from the first Dark Prophecy can be cast at instant speed, you can use it before the second Dark Prophecy trigger resolves. This could be useful if the card you draw is some kind of instant speed life gain, such as Crypt Incursion

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.