I have questions regarding this ruling on Ashiok, Dream Render:
If Ashiok’s last ability targets an opponent, the cards put into their graveyard will be among the cards exiled by the ability. No player may take any actions between the time the cards are put into a graveyard and the time your opponents’ graveyards are all exiled.
Suppose player A uses Ashiok, Dream Render's -1 loyalty ability to target player B. Player B puts the top four cards of their library into their graveyard. But:
- What if Player B puts Vigor or Hostility into their graveyard as part of those four? Would Vigor or Hostility be shuffled into player B's library?
- What if Player C has Profane Memento on the battlefield? Does player C gain life for each creature that that is put into the graveyard?
The ruling states that a player does not get an action during Ashiok's loyalty ability, but are these effects player abilities?