3

Cosumi claims that I won this game by 37 points:

Go board with even territory between the two sides

[9×9, Level 0] Black(You) Wins by 37 Points - Go Browser Game COSUMI

But it looks even to me.

Am I missing something, or does the site sometimes get the score completely wrong?

EDIT:

Strange. The next morning, the same URL shows the upper-right corner as captured:

enter image description here

That might account for the score but, as far as I can tell, White still owns that territory.

Something strange is going on here. (Does Cosumi have a bug-reporting mechanism?)

  • 3
    The score is wrong, both white groups are alive – Pablo Lozano Sep 7 at 9:23
1

You are right that the top right belongs to White with correct play, but according to the programme Sabaki White wins by one point (because they have a captive). It is conceivable, but somewhat unlikely, that White could make enough errors for Black to win.

The score

Sabaki calculates the score like this for area scoring:

enter image description here

and like this with territory scoring:

enter image description here

The top right

To be on the safe side, I plugged your SGF into KataGo (via Sabaki), and it showed me a ko in the top right that Black cannot win: not only do they have hardly any threats, even if they did, they could not finish the ko in their favour.

The sequence that KataGo found was this:

$$Bcm1 Trying for a ko
$$ +---------+
$$ |..XOO.a25|
$$ |.X.XO.O1c|
$$ |..,XXO4d3|
$$ |.XXXXXOOO|
$$ |..XOXOXXO|
$$ |XXOOOOX.X|
$$ |OOOOOX.X.|
$$ |....OX.X.|
$$ |.O..OOX..|
$$ +---------+

Unfortunately for Black, White simply has to connect with ➅ at a and Black has no way of finishing the ko to kill White. White can just wait for Black to run out of threats and then capture at c and d.

Black’s only chance is if White plays the ko wrongly, for example:

$$Wcm6 White messes up (9 retakes, 13 @ 7)
$$ +---------+
$$ |..XOO36OX|
$$ |.X.XO2OX1|
$$ |0.,XXOO.X|
$$ |9XXXXXOOO|
$$ |57XOXOXXO|
$$ |XXOOOOX.X|
$$ |OOOOOXxX.|
$$ |....OX.X.|
$$ |.O..OOX..|
$$ +---------+
  • capturing ➅ instead of connecting at ⓫,
  • threatening with ➉ instead of the deadlier threat at x,
  • missing x again after Black takes at ⓫ and therefore giving up the ko, so
  • Black wins by 27 (area) or 26 (territory).
| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.