1

The rules are not clear. Every turn I can make a suggestion once I am in a room, but do I have to? Can I just end my turn?

2 Answers 2

4

From the rules here

As soon as you enter a room, make a suggestion.

It's very common in games rules to use the word 'may' when something is optional. The rules use the word 'may' in other places. This would mean that making a suggestion is compulsory on entering a room.

However you may not remain in a room on your next turn. (and thus make another suggestion)

You may make only one Suggestion after entering a particular room. To make your next Suggestion, you must either enter a different Room or, sometime after your next turn remain in a particular Room.

Thats not how I was taught the game as a child and we just stayed in the same room making suggestions! So I've learnt something new today.

2
  • What if you are very close to make an accusation because only few clues left, do you just start making random suggestions even though you’ve already mentioned it earlier?
    – Kerberos
    Oct 3, 2020 at 8:02
  • 2
    That for you as the player to make a tactical decision on. I'm just answering the rules question! as it is not 'may' then you 'must' make a suggestion on entering a room. Oct 3, 2020 at 9:21
1

If the question is, "Am I required to make a suggestion whenever I enter a room?", then strictly speaking the answer is yes. The rules explicitly say "make a suggestion".

However (except in the case of the first time in the game that a player enters a room) in practice you can effectively avoid this by simply repeating a suggestion that you or someone else has previously made.

And making it look like a mistake could be more advantageous than giving people the information that you are refraining from making a suggestion.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .