6

Extinction Event reads

Choose odd or even. Exile each creature with converted mana cost of the chosen value.

Why can't I respond to my opponent's choice of odd/even, for example by activating my Witch's Oven? Making this choice is the part of the spell so once the player chooses, shouldn't I be able to react as it still should be on the stack? Is this just an Arena bug?

1 Answer 1

12

You cannot react to the even/odd choice in Extinction Event because that choice is made during the spell's resolution.

In general, you don't make all kinds of choices while casting a spell. As specified in rules 601.2b-d, you choose modes, splices, other cost modifiers, targets, and how to divide or distribute an effect among targets. Any other choice, like even/odd in Extinction Event, doesn't happen until the spell resolves.

While the choice on Extinction Event may look similar to a modal choice, a modal choice specifically requires you to choose from a list of actions, so an instruction to "choose" other things is different.


This fact is also mentioned in a Gatherer ruling on Extinction Event:

You choose odd or even while Extinction Event is resolving. Players can’t take any actions between the time you make that choice and the time some creatures go extinct.

3
  • 1
    Thanks, I was exactly thinking about the modal choice (did not know the name), which is also why it looked weird to me. I should have checked if for rulings first though.
    – eXPRESS
    Nov 28, 2020 at 11:30
  • You also make decisions related to costs during casting, but that's pretty obvious.
    – ikegami
    Nov 30, 2020 at 6:34
  • You're right. I expanded that part a little to make it more accurate.
    – murgatroid99
    Nov 30, 2020 at 6:59

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .