We were playing Widow’s walk last night and happened to start haunt 59 which is the Fleshchild one. Since we had no monster, but one of us became a traitor, he kept his omen/item cards and started hunting us. We had a case where in a combat, the traitor attacked one of the players and after both rolled, they attempted to use the bloodstone card. Nowhere in the rules is explained, can they be used after both players in the combat rolled their dices? When is the combat declared finished? Its just stated “once per turn”, but can such cards be used after the opponent attempted a roll or it should be after the card holder roll?

1 Answer 1


The Bloodstone Omen Card says:

Once per turn, you may lose 1 from any trait to add 2 dice (maximum of 8 dice) to your trait roll.

An Attack (or Defense) roll is not considered a Trait Roll. The traitor would not be able to use this card to buff their attack. Trait Rolls are explained in more detail on page 13 of the 2nd Edition Rulebook.

Trait Rolls: Sometimes a card, room tile, or haunt tells you to attempt a roll based on one of the explorer's traits (Might, Speed, Knowledge, or Sanity). When that happens, roll dice equal to the number your explorer currently has in that trait... An attack roll isn't a trait roll, even though it involves Might or some other trait.

A Trait Roll would be if a room card tells you to make a Might/Speed/Sanity/Knowledge roll, the haunt tells you to make a sanity roll to do XYZ (besides attacking), or if a room tile has some sort of trait specific text (such as the Collapsed Room tile where it asks you to make a Speed Roll).

In short, if you are attacking another player, or defending against an attack of some kind where another player is rolling dice against you, this is not considered a Trait Roll.

  • Thanks for the clarification! However, if we presume that he was not a traitor, can he use the Bloodstone after the opponent rolled their dice for defense/attack? Sep 20, 2022 at 8:15
  • 1
    No, regardless if the person holding The Bloodstone is the Traitor or not - an Attack or Defense roll is not considered a Trait Roll which is what the Bloodstone would need to trigger its ability. Sep 20, 2022 at 14:18
  • 1
    It is worth emphasizing that if it happens to be that a traitor happens to make a trait roll (for example, if the traitor needs to make a knowledge check for some haunt related action) they may indeed use the bloodstone's effect. Most trait rolls however would have occurred as a part of an event or tile effect and per the rules the traitor may choose to completely ignore such effects.
    – JMoravitz
    Sep 21, 2022 at 13:32

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .