5

I'm being trying to find this variant. It's a variant where, when you have a full column, you can place a disk into that column and push downwards, causing all the disks to go down one row except for the bottom disk with then falls out of the bottom?

2
  • Due to the way the reset mechanism works in Connect 4, this variant could easily cause the entire game to be reset when you attempt to push 1 column down through the bottom.
    – GendoIkari
    Apr 29, 2023 at 23:30
  • 1
    It’s not using a normal rack, pushing down only effects the column the disk is placed in, and only when it’s full. Apr 30, 2023 at 3:49

2 Answers 2

2

This is not an official variant of the game. It's similar to the "PopOut" variant by Hasbro, and seems like a totally viable house-rule variant if you have a Connect 4 Revised Edition board.

Hasbro released a new version of Connect 4 in 2008, the Connect 4 Revised Edition, that has the ability to remove the bottom checker from just a single column without messing up the rest of the board. The intention of this was to support two new game variants (PopOut and Pop 10). The one most similar to the rules you describe is PopOut:

Play PopOut just like the Original Connect 4. However, on your turn, you can choose either to drop a counter in OR pop one out of the bottom row.

Note: You can only drop in or pop out counters of your own colour.

There is also Connect 4 Revised Second Edition, which adds two more official variants (Five in a Row and Power Up), but neither of these are relevant.

The rules you describe are unlikely to show up as on official variant for the game without a hardware update. On the classic Connect 4 board, trying to push a checker into a full column could very easily reset the whole board by accident. Meanwhile, the Revised Connect 4 boards are designed to allow for removal of the bottom checker, but you do so by popping it out of the column, not by pushing a new checker in at the top. While the Revised boards fully support this style of play, you would need to pop out the checker first and then add the new checker second.

Don't let any of this stop you! House rules can be great. It seems like a cool rule, and if you have a Connect 4 board that supports it, go for it.

1
  • I think that's the one, maybe. Jun 2, 2023 at 7:15
2

This is not a well-known variant.

But it sounds like an interesting House rule

If it was a common variant it would be mentioned in one of the Connect4 variant lists which appear on BGG, Wiki, ultraboardgames, Hasbro-rules.

Searching through lists of Connect4 variants, I spotted two variants with some similarity to the push-down rule you are looking for:

  1. "Popout" allows to drop a disk from the bottom:

The game play is like the original Connect4 except on your turn you can do:

  1. Drop a checker, or
  2. Pop one of your own checkers out of the bottom row.
  1. In "Power Up" each player have several special disks, one of them is the Anvil, which when placed immediately pops out all the checkers below it, leaving only the anvil on the bottom row.

Sources:

  1. BGG: Variations on four-in-a-row
  2. BGG: the Tic Tac Toe Family Reunion
  3. Wiki: Connect_Four #Rule_variations
  4. ultraboardgames: variations
  5. Hasbro rules archives
10
  • I remember when I was younger playong the game with a physical rack that coul actually have the bottom disks fall out. Apr 29, 2023 at 15:55
  • @blademan9999, yes I also had a physical rack that could actually have the bottom disks fall out. It was used to initialize the board after a game ends. Removing all the disks.
    – Cohensius
    Apr 30, 2023 at 18:14
  • 4
    Chat GPT should not be used for answers.
    – Joe W
    May 1, 2023 at 2:27
  • 2
    GPT answers are considered bad practice on most of the sites that I have seen. Even if it is a supplemental part it should be avoided.
    – Joe W
    May 1, 2023 at 23:26
  • 1
    @JoeW, ok I deleted GPT's answer
    – Cohensius
    May 2, 2023 at 8:22

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .