0

In this 5 player game, it appears to be impossible to reach the 8 house threshold for phase 2, so we house ruled phase 2 if all phase 1 houses are sold. Was that a good call? Power Grid board game stalled in phase 1

I'm told it's the Benelux version with new plants, and the other side of the board (Middle Europe) does have enough cities.

Benelux rules

2 Answers 2

2

You have the rules wrong

In a 5 player game, 7 cities are required to trigger step 2. I'm finding it difficult to find an online copy of the official rules for the original (non-"recharged") variant, but here's the table from page 7 of my Rio Grande copy (copyright 2004, 2011 2F-Spiele):

Photo of page 7 of the Power Grid rulebook, showing how various properties change with the number of players

The official Benelux rules from the Rio Grande website do not change the trigger conditions, so my current theory is that whoever did the "translation" of the rules into the Dutch version you have shown took some fairly large liberties they shouldn't have taken.

4
  • 1
    How do you know OP's not recharged? (FWIW, this particular aspect seems to be the same in both) Commented Aug 31 at 12:39
  • 2
    @AndrewSavinykh Fair point. I sort of assumed they would have said "Recharged" if they were playing that version but I admit that may not be a correct assumption. But as you say, doesn't matter. Commented Aug 31 at 12:44
  • It's my first time, new plants Benelux, not Recharged, and this map has only 5x7=35 cities. Commented Aug 31 at 13:31
  • @CeesTimmerman Hmmm, interesting. Updated this answer to show that the offical Rio Grande rules do not have that table you have shown. Commented Aug 31 at 13:41
0

The Benelux map only has 5x7=35 cities, which is too few for 5 players. We should have played the Middle Europe map limited to 40 cities, but the house rule of starting phase 2 when phase 1 houses are sold out still made for a close and fun game:

Power Grid Benelux, new plants, too many players for this map.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .