Return to Question

I had Necroskitter out and my opponent has Clone which cloned some 3/3 monster. I play Puncture Blast to kill it. I believe that I get Clone card because of the following steps

1. Cast puncture bolt
2. Target Clone creature
3. Opponent has no response so there for it dies
4. Because it has -1/-1 counter when it was sent to the graveyard it triggers my Necroskitter
5. I get to put Clone into my battlefield

I believe I am right but my friend says that [Clone][2] comes back as 0/0 as therefore dies. Who is right?

I had Necroskitter out and my opponent has Clone which cloned some 3/3 monster. I play Puncture Blast to kill it. I believe that I get Clone card because of the following steps

1. Cast puncture bolt
2. Target Clone creature
3. Opponent has no response so there for it dies
4. Because it has -1/-1 counter when it was sent to the graveyard it triggers my Necroskitter
5. I get to put Clone into my battlefield

I believe I am right but my friend says that [Clone][2] comes back as 0/0 as therefore dies. Who is right?

I had Necroskitter out and my opponent has Clone which cloned some 3/3 monster. I play Puncture Blast to kill it. I believe that I get Clone card because of the following steps

1. Cast puncture bolt
2. Target Clone creature
3. Opponent has no response so there for it dies
4. Because it has -1/-1 counter when it was sent to the graveyard it triggers my Necroskitter
5. I get to put Clone into my battlefield

I believe I am right but my friend says that Clone comes back as 0/0 as therefore dies. Who is right?

I had Necroskitter out and my opponent has Clone which cloned some 3/3 monster. I play Puncture Blast to kill it. I believe that I get Clone card because of the following steps

1. Cast puncture bolt
2. Target Clone creature
3. Opponent has no response so there for it dies
4. Because it has -1/-1 counter when it was sent to the graveyard it triggers my Necroskitter
5. I get to put Clone into my battlefield

I believe I am right but my friend says that [Clone][2] comes back as 0/0 as therefore dies. Who is right?

I had Necroskitter out and my opponent has Clone which cloned some 3/3 monster. I play Puncture Blast to kill it. I believe that I get Clone card because of the following steps

1. Cast puncture bolt
2. Target Clone creature
3. Opponent has no response so there for it dies
4. Because it has -1/-1 counter when it was sent to the graveyard it triggers my Necroskitter
5. I get to play Clone and I choose a card for my clone to copy

I believe I am right but my friend says that Clone comes back as 0/0 as therefore dies. Who is right?

I had Necroskitter out and my opponent has Clone which cloned some 3/3 monster. I play Puncture Blast to kill it. I believe that I get Clone card because of the following steps

1. Cast puncture bolt
2. Target Clone creature
3. Opponent has no response so there for it dies
4. Because it has -1/-1 counter when it was sent to the graveyard it triggers my Necroskitter
5. I get to put Clone into my battlefield

I believe I am right but my friend says that Clone comes back as 0/0 as therefore dies. Who is right?