I'm a little unclear on the The Magic the Gathering card Hickory Woodlot

enter image description here

Hickory Woodlot enters the battlefield tapped with two depletion counters on it.

Tap, Remove a depletion counter from Hickory Woodlot: Add {G}{G} to your mana pool. If there are no depletion counters on Hickory Woodlot, sacrifice it.

The card is a land, so can it be tapped without removing a depletion counter to produce mana as normal?

Do you sacrifice it immediately after removing the counter? In other words do you have to have counters on it to use it's ability or can you use it one last time without?

  • 5
    If for some reason it existed on the battlefield with no counters, you would not be able to activate its ability since you could not pay the cost.
    – ikegami
    Jan 7, 2014 at 19:19

1 Answer 1


Lands can only have the abilities printed on them. Any land that has one of the basic land subtypes (Plains, Island, etc.) also has an inherent ability to tap for one mana of the appropriate color. Hickory Woodlot is a land, but it has no basic land subtype, so it has no additional abilities of that sort besides what is printed. You can only tap this card for the ability using the depletion counters, to add 2 Green mana to your mana pool.

As to your second question, You perform all steps of an ability in order. First, you pay all costs (in this case, tapping and removing a depletion counter) and then, you perform all effects. The first effect is to generate the mana, then, there is a check against the depletion counters. This will check AFTER the counter has been removed, so you can essentially use this ability twice, and immediately after the second use, the land is sacrificed.

  • thanks for the edit, i wasnt sure of the exact way to refer to the basic land subtypes so went for a broad and hopefully reasonably understandable approach. Obviously the rules appropriate wording is better, thanks for the clarification!
    – Patters
    Jan 7, 2014 at 14:47

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .